
The Disappearing First Rung: Artificial Intelligence and the Changing Architecture of Early-Career Employment
An examination of entry-level employment, technological displacement and the implications for youth economic opportunity.
by Cherriss V Manzi
Abstract
The traditional transition from education to employment has relied upon entry-level positions through which young people acquire experience, develop professional judgement and progress towards higher-value work. Emerging evidence suggests that this pathway is undergoing structural change. Artificial intelligence (AI), combined with evolving organisational practices and economic pressures, may be reducing demand for the routine cognitive tasks historically undertaken by junior employees. This article examines the emerging evidence and considers the implications for labour-market participation, human capital formation and alternative routes into economic activity.
The erosion of entry-level employment
In August 2025, Stanford economist Erik Brynjolfsson, together with Bharat Chandar and Ruyu Chen, published Canaries in the Coal Mine? Six Facts about the Recent Employment Effects of Artificial Intelligence. Their research identified a concerning divergence in employment outcomes between younger and more experienced workers in occupations highly exposed to generative AI.
The study's August 2026 revision found that employment among workers aged 22–25 in AI-exposed occupations was 19% below the level implied by employment trends among their less-exposed peers. Importantly, the divergence was primarily associated with reduced hiring rather than increased dismissals (Brynjolfsson, Chandar and Chen, 2025, revised 2026).
These findings suggest a potentially significant structural problem: the disappearance of the first rung of the career ladder.
Historically, junior positions have provided employers with relatively inexpensive labour while enabling young workers to accumulate experience and develop tacit knowledge. Tasks such as basic research, administrative processing, preliminary analysis and routine drafting have served both productive and developmental purposes.
Generative AI increasingly performs many of these activities. Organisations may therefore become more productive without expanding junior headcount. Yet the elimination of routine tasks also risks removing the experiences through which future professionals develop expertise.
This creates a paradox: the economy may continue to require experienced workers while progressively weakening the pathways through which experience is acquired.
A broader structural transition
The British labour market provides further grounds for concern, although the evidence does not establish AI as the sole cause.
The Institute of Student Employers reported an 8% decline in graduate recruitment during 2024/25. Recruitment subsequently increased by 4% in 2025/26, but growth was uneven and concentrated among relatively few employers (ISE, 2025; 2026).
Research by Lambert and Schindler (2026), published through the London School of Economics' Centre for Economic Performance, complicates the technological displacement argument. Their analysis suggests that remote working may explain a substantial proportion of declining junior recruitment, independently of generative AI.
The emerging picture is therefore not simply one of technological replacement, but of multiple structural changes converging upon the earliest stages of working life.
The potential consequences extend beyond immediate unemployment. Persistent barriers to labour-market entry may delay human capital accumulation, reduce lifetime earnings potential and reinforce inequalities between those with access to professional networks and those without.
Entrepreneurship as an alternative pathway
If traditional organisational structures provide fewer opportunities for young people to gain experience, policy must consider alternative mechanisms through which productive capabilities can develop.
Entrepreneurship, self-employment and portfolio working offer potential routes through which individuals can acquire commercial experience, exercise agency and participate directly in economic activity.
These pathways should not be regarded as universal substitutes for employment. Entrepreneurship entails substantial uncertainty, financial risk and unequal access to resources. Nevertheless, enterprise education, supported experimentation, mentoring and access to markets could provide additional mechanisms for developing capabilities previously acquired through entry-level employment.
The challenge is therefore not simply to protect existing jobs, but to reconsider how economies enable inexperienced individuals to become economically productive.
Conclusion
The possible disappearance of the first rung presents a structural challenge to established models of education, employment and career progression.
Although the causal contribution of artificial intelligence remains contested, evidence of changing early-career recruitment patterns warrants attention.
An economy that increasingly rewards experience while reducing opportunities to acquire it risks creating a self-reinforcing barrier to labour-market participation.
The policy response must consequently extend beyond conventional job creation towards the development of multiple accessible pathways into economic activity, including employment, entrepreneurship and self-employment.
The fundamental question is no longer simply how young people find their first job, but how they obtain their first meaningful opportunity to create economic value.
Image Credit: Andrew Neel
References
Brynjolfsson, E., Chandar, B. and Chen, R. (2025, revised 2026). Canaries in the Coal Mine? Six Facts about the Recent Employment Effects of Artificial Intelligence. Stanford Digital Economy Lab. https://digitaleconomy.stanford.edu/publication/canaries-in-the-coal-mine-six-facts-about-the-recent-employment-effects-of-artificial-intelligence/
Institute of Student Employers (2025). Student Recruitment Survey 2025. https://ise.org.uk/
Institute of Student Employers (2026). Student Recruitment Report 2026. https://ise.org.uk/
Lambert, P.J. and Schindler, Y. (2026). The Broken Ladder: AI, Remote Work, and Early-Career Hiring. CEP Discussion Paper No. 2193. Centre for Economic Performance, London School of Economics and Political Science. https://cep.lse.ac.uk/_NEW/PUBLICATIONS/abstract.asp?index=12306

